In “Living with Music,” Ralph Ellison reflects on the significance of music in defining his life through shaping their unique cultural and social identity. His experiences with music affect his attitude towards the various social spaces he lives in. Later in life, when he again met up with music, he had different experiences from his childhood music experiences. Ellison had a neighbor living on top of his apartment who practiced music. The neighbor’s notes were always off, and he bought a speaker system to cover and contradict her music. After moving to his new apartment, he realized that he missed the music he heard in his old apartment. Therefore, based on his experiences, music is a reminder of the past and future aspirations, as well as helping one move past their problems. According to Ellison, music is a source of inspiration for the troubled.
Oliver Sacks’s “A Bolt from the Blue” highlights the association between music and psychology. An example is a lighting-struck doctor who then had a passion for music. Dr. Cicoria, who was not a music fan pre-accident, suddenly developed a passion for music in his post-accident life. Another example is Salimah, who had a brain tumor. After the brain tumor was removed, she had a changed personality. Therefore, from these examples, it can be resolved that musical identity formations are related to brain science to a significant degree. In the case of Cicoria, the lightning strike might have open his brain to his passion and hidden music talent. Therefore, musical identity is hidden in the bran, and it may take an incident to experience their positive musical identity formations.


